Welcome to Sherrilli's Pizzeria
Nestled in Sellersburg, Indiana, Sherrilli's Pizzeria offers a cozy dining experience that marries quality ingredients with a welcoming atmosphere. Renowned for its hot, freshly prepared pizzas and a variety of toppings, patrons rave about the lunch buffet and mouthwatering wings. The thin, crispy crusts and signature flavors leave lasting impressions, with highlights like the 16" Supreme and BBQ Chicken pizzas. Customers consistently note the friendly staff who contribute to the inviting vibe. Sherrilli's isn’t just a meal; it’s a community gathering spot, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers and families alike. Don’t miss out on the delicious offerings here!
- 496 N Indiana Ave, Sellersburg, IN 47172, United States Hotline: +1 812-246-3346
Welcome to Sherrilli's Pizzeria, a delightful gem nestled in Sellersburg, Indiana. Located at 496 N Indiana Ave, this inviting eatery serves up mouthwatering dishes that keep locals and visitors alike craving more. With a focus on exceptional quality and a welcoming atmosphere, Sherrilli's aims to elevate your pizza experience.
Sherrilli's is renowned for its lunch buffet, which customers rave about for its consistently hot pizza and a wide variety of toppings. One satisfied diner, Elliott Pinegar, highlights the value of the flat $10 price for an endless selection of delicious pies. Despite the occasional wait during peak times, the piping hot pizzas make it well worth it.
For pizza lovers who enjoy robust flavors, Jani Sherrill recommends the pepperoni and sausage combination, which she passionately stands by after working at the pizzeria for six years. It’s here that you can also take advantage of a fun promotion—screenshot her review for $5 off your order!
But the culinary highlights don't stop at pizza. Customers like James Heath guide you to try the house flavor wings, described as "straight money," along with large soft pretzels served with warm cheese—perfect for sharing or indulging solo. The thin, crispy crust of the pizzas has received praise for being cooked to perfection, delivering flavors that keep diners returning for more.
Sherrilli's also boasts a friendly staff, which aligns perfectly with the sense of community that patrons, like Mona Owens, feel the moment they walk through the door. It’s not just about the food; it’s about the connections made and the experience created. Diners frequently find themselves enchanted by the atmosphere and the staff, who treat guests like family.
Whether you’re stopping by after a long trip, like Karen Jarvis did after a Florida winter, or finding a quick lunch spot while on the road, Sherrilli's Pizzeria promises a memorable meal. The blend of delicious food and friendly service makes Sherrilli's a standout choice in the area. So next time you're in Sellersburg, don’t just pass by—come and experience the flavors, the warmth, and the community at Sherrilli’s Pizzeria!

Great lunch buffet! Pizza is very hot, with a nice variety. When busy you might have to wait a few minutes for more pizza, but it will be piping hot and loaded with toppings. Well worth the flat 10 cash price!

hehe hi guys yes I work here but I can still review right?? I personally enjoy pepperoni and sausage, and that’s after eating this pizza all the time for 6 years now! anyways if you’re reading this review you should come check us out, if you screenshot this review and show it at the counter you get 5 off your order!

Dudes working here are very friendly... Try the house flavor wings!!!! They are straight money!! The pizza didn't look anything special but it was cooked perfect, then the crust was thin and crispy, just right on point!!! My kids absolutely loved the large soft pretzel with warm cheese.... Again props to the owners/management as these young dudes working were right on point with everything... Can't wait to stop back in next time we're in the neighborhood

We were on our way home from Florida where we spent the winter and were craving Sherrilli's pizza. We called about 15 minutes from finally getting home and they said it would be 20 to 25 minutes. We got there 14 minutes later and it was already done!!! We brought it home and it was Delicious!!!

The food is great love it. The only thing that I feel needs a little with is they seem to tell everyone that the wait time is 20 to 25 mins but it takes longer than that every time I've ordered from there.

Was in town for work and got two pizzas for lunch, delicious , hot, fresh pizza really hit the spot. 16" Supreme and 14" BBQ Chicken was outstanding. Me and my crew really enjoyed it. Didn't catch the name of the lady that helped me. But she was very friendly. My pick up time was 11:50 and it was hot and coming out the over wheb I walked in. Highly recommend you guys. When i am back in the area, guarantee a return for sure.!!! Thanks Again Steven Strange, Elizabethtown, Kentucky

The pizza was amazing! But the people made it even more so. Even if the pizza was only good, I would still give them 5 stars. Felt like they were your friends and family.

Always amazing pizza and made just right. Doesn’t last long in my house!